By Author 
Running a business comes with a constant need for funds be it to expand operations, buy machinery, manage day-to-day expenses, or meet working capital requirements. In India, MSME Loans and Mudra Loans are two popular financing options designed to support small businesses from working capital and expansion to equipment purchases. While MSME loans serve a wide spectrum of small and medium businesses, MUDRA loans focus on micro and emerging enterprises, often offering collateral-free access to credit.
But which one is better for your business?
MSME Loan Or Mudra Loan
In this blog, we’ll break down both schemes, compare them feature-by-feature, and help you choose the right one to power your growth.
Understanding these Two Financing Options
Before diving into comparisons, let’s quickly understand the core difference between these two vital funding sources.
1. What is an MSME Loan?
An MSME Loan is a broad category of credit facility offered to Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises. This is a common loan product from most banks and NBFCs, tailored for companies with more established financial records.
- Primary Goal: To meet comprehensive operational and large-scale expansion needs.
- Availability: Widely available across the banking and financial sector.
2. What is a Mudra Loan?
The Micro Units Development and Refinance Agency (MUDRA) Loan is a specific government-backed scheme under the Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana (PMMY). It is explicitly designed for the smallest business owners and micro-enterprises who often struggle to access formal credit.
- Primary Goal: To provide quick, collateral-free credit for grassroots-level entrepreneurs.
- Structure: Divided into three simple categories based on the amount needed.
- Shishu (for startups/immediate needs)
- Kishore
- Tarun
Key Differences Between MSME Loans and Mudra Loans
The decision often comes down to two factors: how much money you need and what kind of business records you maintain.
| Feature | MSME Loan (General) | Mudra Loan (PMMY) |
|---|---|---|
| Loan Amount (Maximum) | Can go up to ₹2 Crore or more. | Strictly capped at ₹10 Lakh. |
| Collateral Requirement | Varies. Required for larger amounts; unsecured options exist (e.g., CGTMSE). | Mostly Unsecured/Collateral-Free. A core promise of the scheme. |
| Target Business Size | Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (the entire spectrum). | Non-corporate, Non-farm Micro and Small units only. |
| Documentation Depth | Requires detailed financial statements, ITR, GST, and audited balance sheets. | Requires minimal documents (ID, business proof); simpler process. |
| Primary Use | Infrastructure, heavy machinery, large working capital, major expansion. | Small-scale needs, tool purchase, micro-unit working capital. |
| Governing Framework | Broad category of bank/NBFC products, often utilizing schemes like CGTMSE. | Specific central government flagship scheme (PMMY). |
Criteria to Apply: Who Can Get These Loans?
Your business profile determines which door you can walk through.
Eligibility and Documentation for MSME Loan
If you run a medium-sized enterprise or need significant funding, prepare for a formal process.
- Business Registration: Mandatory Udyam Registration to confirm MSME status.
- Financial Track Record: You must provide proof of repayment capacity through GST returns, bank statements, and audited financial statements.
- Business Vintage: Lenders often prefer businesses that have been operational for at least 1–3 years.
- Credit Health: The promoter and business should maintain a good credit score (generally 750+).
Eligibility and Documentation for Mudra Loan
The rules here are designed to be accessible to everyone, including first-time entrepreneurs.
- Business Type: Applicable for micro-enterprises in manufacturing, trading, or services.
- Categories: Your loan must fit into one of the three categories:
- Shishu: Up to ₹50,000 (for startups/immediate needs)
- Kishore: ₹50,000 to ₹5 lakh
- Tarun: ₹5 lakh to ₹10 lakh
- Documentation: Minimal. ID proof, address proof, business existence proof (like a shop license or invoice proof), and a basic business plan.
Analyzing the Cost: Interest Rates
The rate of interest directly impacts your profit margin. Always compare the true Annual Percentage Rate (APR), which includes all fees.
| Loan Type | Typical Interest Rate Range | Key Deciding Factor |
|---|---|---|
| MSME Loans | 8% to 18% p.a. | Varies based on collateral offered, credit score, and specific lending institution. |
| Mudra Loans | 9.30% to 12% p.a. | Set by the lending bank based on the PMMY guidelines; often lower for Shishu loans. |
Export to Sheets
Pro Tip: While a general MSME loan might advertise a slightly lower starting rate (e.g., 8%), only highly creditworthy, established firms with excellent collateral receive it. Mudra rates are generally competitive and predictable for micro-borrowers.
Which Loan is Better for Your Business
Choosing the better loan is not about which is universally superior; it’s about which loan perfectly matches your business requirements and stage of growth.
Choose the Mudra Loan If:
- Your Need is Small: You require funds ₹10 Lakh or less.
- You Lack Collateral: You are a micro-unit and do not have property or assets to pledge.
- You Need Speed: You prioritize quick approval and faster disbursal.
- You are a Startup: You are a first-time entrepreneur or a new business with minimal financial history.
Final Takeaway: Mudra Loan is your go-to for immediate, accessible, collateral-free micro-funding.
Choose the MSME Loan If:
- Your Need is Large: You require funds over ₹10 Lakh (e.g., ₹50 Lakh or ₹1 Crore).
- You are Expanding Significantly: You need to invest in heavy machinery, land, or a major infrastructure upgrade.
- You Have Records: Your business has strong, audited financial statements and a good GST compliance history.
- You Can Offer Security: You are prepared to offer collateral to secure a large loan at a favorable interest rate.
Final Takeaway: MSME Loan is the right choice for established, growing businesses demanding substantial capital.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What is the key difference between MSME Loan & Mudra Loan?
MSME Loan is a general category for all sizes of small businesses, with high loan limits. Mudra Loan is a specific, collateral-free scheme for the smallest micro-businesses, capped at ₹10 Lakh.
2. How can I avail an MSME Loan?
Apply directly to a bank or NBFC. You will need to provide your full business documents, financial statements, and GST/ITR records. The process is formal and detailed.
3. How can I avail a Mudra Loan?
Visit any participating public or private sector bank, MFI, or apply through the Udyamimitra portal. You must provide ID, address proof, and basic business details under the Shishu, Kishore, or Tarun category.
4. How many MSME loan options are available?
Many! Besides Mudra, options include Working Capital Loans (for daily expenses), Term Loans (for asset purchase), Overdraft Facilities, and the CGTMSE-backed loan (collateral-free up to ₹5 Crore for eligible units).
5. Do Mudra Loans require collateral?
No. The PMMY scheme aims to provide unsecured credit, making the loan mostly collateral-free.
6. Can a business apply for a Mudra Loan if it is not formally registered?
Yes. This is a key benefit. While registration (like Udyam) is helpful, the scheme specifically targets micro-businesses, vendors, and small entrepreneurs who may not be formally registered yet.
7. What is the maximum tenure for repayment in both loans?
The maximum tenure for a Mudra Loan is typically 5 to 7 years. A general MSME Term Loan for high value can have a much longer tenure, often up to 10 or 15 years.
8. Are interest rates fixed for MSME and Mudra Loans?
No. Interest rates are variable and depend on the bank’s internal lending rate (like MCLR or RLLR), the borrower’s credit profile, and the specific category of the loan.
9. Can I get a second Mudra Loan after repaying the first?
Yes. Successful repayment of your first Mudra Loan is highly encouraged, and it makes you eligible to apply for a higher-category Mudra Loan (e.g., upgrading from Shishu to Kishore) to fund your business expansion.
10. Can startups get MSME Loans?
Yes. Startups registered under MSME can apply for general MSME loans, often through specific schemes designed for new enterprises, but proving business viability remains essential for approval.